When I first discovered Enchanted Polish, I also found out that many of the colors are hard to find. I swore to myself that I didn't need October 2013, a gorgeous dark gray holo. And so I purchased other gray holos as well as Enchanted Polish's holo top coat, Djinn in a Bottle to transform my non-holo grays.
Then someone had one for sale at a great price. And I couldn't resist, even though I had crossed it off of my ISO long ago. I figured why not buy it and see if I do need it, or if I already had a dupe for it. Thinking of you, dear readers, I decided to get it and then compare all of my grays to it in order to solve the mystery.
I didn't realize I had so many grays until I started this project. Luckily, I keep my stash on pinterest and on a free android app, so I can quickly look at what I have and choose what could be possible dupes. I've never been a fan of the spreadsheet method, I'm a visual person, so if you are too, it's a good idea to make a pinterest board or use an app to keep track of your collection. Did you ever buy an awesome color only to go home and find out you already owned it? I think we've all made that mistake! That's why I recommend the app, because when you're in the store and see that color on clearance, you can just take out your phone and check to see if you already own it.
Anyhow, onto the dupe hunt! First I took out all the grays I thought could work, either alone or with a Djinn topper.
From left to right we have: Enchanted Polish October 2013, Chanel Orage, Chanel Black Pearl, Chanel Graphite, Liquid Sky Lacquer Storm Break, OPI Nein Nein Nein Ok Fine, Sally Hansen Gunmetal, Mod Lacquer Men in Black, and Sally Hansen Magnetic Graphite Gravity
And here's Enchanted Polish Djinn in a Bottle
First, I swatched all the colors, two coats each, in the order I listed above
Now here comes the real work: a head to head comparison of each one
(October 2013 is on top in all the head to head pics)
First we have Chanel Orage topped with Djinn
As you can see, Orage is too dark - no dupe here
Onward to Chanel Black Pearl topped with Djinn
As you can see, Black Pearl makes October look brown, which it isn't, so they definitely aren't dupes
Next Chanel Graphite, which is already a fine glitter but I put Djinn on it anyway
Graphite is too light, I do like how it looks with Djinn though :)
Then we move on to Liquid Sky Lacquer Storm Break, which I originally purchased because I couldn't find October for a good price. So this was the moment I was waiting for
I can't believe I am saying this, but Storm Break is just too holo to be a dupe. I did not put Djinn over this because it is already holo.
Moving on to OPI Nein Nein Nein Ok Fine topped with Djinn
It is too dark and olive toned to be a dupe, oh well.
Then I tried Sally Hansen Gunmetal topped with Djinn
Gunmetal is way too blue gray to be a dupe
So we move on to the other gray holo I have, Mod Lacquer Men in Black, not topped with Djinn because already holo
Men in Black is gorgeous, but too light and too holo to be a dupe
Finally we have Sally Hansen Magnetic Graphite Gravity topped with Djinn. I did not use the magnet on this obviously
It's too light but probably the closest to being a dupe
I hope you enjoyed this post and if you check out my stash and want to see any other comparisons, let me know! I am happy to help you find dupes! In fact, I spent many hours the other night trying to dupe Enchanted Polish's 2 AM Summer Night, and I just did not have the right combo. The purple can be duped by OPI Suzi & The 7 Dusseldorfs but it needs that duochromey green flash and I don't have anything that will make that happen, but I've got the first part of the recipe down!
You can also follow me on Instagram to see my newest nail mail and manis!
Liquid Sky Lacquer can be purchased on their site - she typically restocks every other Saturday at 2pm PST, but follow her page on Facebook for restock news
Mod Lacquer can be found on their site
OPI and Sally Hansen can be found nearly everywhere
Enchanted Polish, as I mentioned, is hard to find - your best bet is Storenvy, Facebook, Instagram, or eBay, also stockists like Mei Mei and Nail Polish Canada. You can sign up for Enchanted Polish's newsletter and find more info on restocks from their Instagram.